Regeneration Review

Home
Join
Newsletter Archives

1998 - No. 2
INSIDE THIS ISSUE

 POPs Global Elimination Negotiations Continue
 Sacred Place Planning Locally
 Warmest Month in 600 Years / Global Warming

   WORK IN PROGRESS
 Japan May Ban TBT
 Manganese in Gasoline

 Aluminum / Alzheimer's Drinking Water Link
 Petition to North America Commission on the Environment / Cooperation on Incinerators and Great Lakes

 MORE ON POPs
 Us Claims 1% Dioxin Emission
 US Girls Reach Puberty At Extremely Young Age




Newsletter of the Department of the Planet Earth, Inc.
701 E Street, SE
Washington, DC 20003
E-mail: planetearth@erols.com
Phone: (202) 543-5450

Membership $20

Editor: Erik Jansson, Executive Director

UN Negotiations for Global Ban of 12 Organochlorines

Greenpeace Women Greeting Delegates

Some of the fifty Greenpeace women greeting delegates

It's taken a long time. Efforts to ban many of the chlorinated pesticides and PCB's started with American author Rachel Carson's book Silent Spring of thirty years ago.

Since then, many individual nations including the United States have banned or severely regulated these chemicals. At the UN Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil in 1992, plans were made to proceed towards a worldwide ban.

Many of you, our members, signed our petition in 1994 to the UN and wrote letters concerning the Land Based Sources of Marine Pollution treaty. We are happy to report that finalization of this treaty is slated for the year 2000.

Diplomats from ninety two nations met again in Montreal for the week of June 29, 1998 to continue negotiations to phase out on a global basis twelve organochlorine chemicals called POPs or persistent organic pollutants under the auspices of the United Nations Environment Programme. [DDT, PCB'S, dioxins, furans, aldrin, chlordane, endrin, hept- achlor, hexachlorobenzene (HCB), mirex, and toxaphene]

The UN delegates were greeted at the door by about fifty Greenpeace women, costumed as if they were pregnant, in a symbolic gesture to remind people that these particular chemicals pose a threat to children and the young of all species.(photo above)

The twelve pesticides and industrial chemicals were chosen for global phaseouts first because many countries have already banned their production and use. Secondly, they have very long lives in the environment. They build up in the food chain and the fat of living things, as well as in mother's milk to poisonous levels.

And third, these chemicals tend to evaporate or attach themselves to the particulates of smoke plumes to travel hundreds and even thousands of miles away from original release. They've been found in every part of the globe, including heavy contamination of the Arctic food chain due to long-distance drift.

Polar Bear Hermaphrodite Cubs

Today, the polar bear is so contaminated with PCB's that these wonderful animals would be considered toxic waste in the United States.

The health effects can be profound. Norwegian scientists report finding four polar bear hermaphrodite cubs with both male and female sex organs. Never before have such high numbers of these birth defects been found. (Chemistry and Industry, July 9, 1998)

All of the 12 chemicals are considered "endocrine disruptors" with dramatic effects on reproduction and behavior as well as leaming ability and -aggressiveness of offspring. A popular book on this issue was written by Dr. Theo Colbom of the World Wildlife Fund entitled, Our Stolen Future. We'll return to the issue.

Scandiavian Initiative Begins Process

The high levels of organochlorine and mercury in the environment of northern nations and in fish - much of it blowing in from other parts of the world - has caused great concern in Iceland and other Scandinavian nations. And they have provided a lot of leadership. The Icelanders eat much seafood.

1998 Aarhus Protocol: Several regional phaseout agreements have already been concluded. The most recent is a POPs phaseout treaty for the Economic Commission for Europe (EEC), which includes the United States, Canada, Russia and Eastern Europe.

Entitled the "Convention on the Long-Range Trans- boundary Air Pollution of Persistent Organic Pollutants" it was adopted in Aarhus, Denmark in June 1998. The convention includes phaseout schedules for 18 organochlorine chemicals but also a program for the phaseout of heavy metals - mercury, cadmium and lead. When ratified by 16 nations, the Aarhus Protocol will take on the binding force of international law.

Montreal Negotiations Seek Inclusion of Developing Nations in POPs Bans

The European negotiations in Denmark were seen as a way to lay a fonnat for a global treaty that will include developing nations, which have been prodigious user of some of the chlorinated pesticides like DDT that now contaminate global environments.

The next step is a separate developing nation negotiation in Buenos Aires in November. The global POPs phaseout treaty is slated to be ready for signing by the end of the year 2000.

Three sticking points are the claim that the insecticide DDT is still necessary to prevent malaria. Secondly, Russia has revealed that they still manufacture PCBs for electric transformer fluid. And third, there was a need for a procedure to add additional POPs for phaseouts in the future.

Reports by ourselves1 and by the World Wildlife Fund pointed out that alternative programs for mosquito control are already being used and that a vaccine for malaria is very close to achievement.

Whom to Write

So far, the US delegation has been very cooperative. After all, the chemicals being considered for phaseout are considered mostly commercially obsolete. Others like dioxins, furans and HCB are unintended contaminants.

The previous letters of our members have been very helpful. If you would like to urge the US delegation to stick with the policy of "POPs Elimination", which entirely different than regulation, you might want to write:

Secretary Madeleine Albright
Secretary of State
Department of State
2201 C Street, NW
Washington, DC 20520

Environmental and medical groups from all around the world have formed a new organization IPEN or International POPs Elimination Network to coordinate citizen efforts. We're a member.

News Brief: In July, consumer advocate Ralph Nader announced plans to create an American Museum of Tort Law in Winsted, Connecticut.

(1) Letter to the UN Ambassadors on Malaria and Mosquito Control, June 15, 1998 (15 pages)

Back to Top


Sacred Place Planning for Local Communities


San Francisco & Maryland Act to Phase Out Pesticides

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors in October, 1996 voted unanimously to reduce cumulative use of pesticides by all city and county departments and contractors by 50 percent between 1996 and 1998, and adopt a complete ban of pesticide use by the year 2000.

An integrated pest management (IPM) program implemented by the city and the county has already been effective, reducing total pesticide use from 4,877 pounds and 372 gallons to 640 pounds and 136 gallons from January to August 1997. Alternatives for pesticide use in urban areas are well developed.

In April, the State of Maryland passed landmark legislation to begin phasing out pesticide use in schools. Schools must notify parents, guardians and staff 24 hours in advance of pesticide use as well as provide information on effects on pregnancy. In elementary schools they will provide more detailed information on the potential health effects.

All schools are required to adopt integrated pest management programs aimed at "minimizing" the use of pesticides (not including baits). The act is mandatory by the 1999-2000 regular school year.

  • National Coalition Against the Misuse of Pesticdes, "Technical Report", 1313 (March 1998)
  • Quarles, William, "Pheromones and non-toxic cockroach control ", The IPM Practitioner XX 516 (May/June 1998)
  • Waste Not, At last: San Francsico has given us the model to phase-out pesticide use", 433 (July 1998)

Delaware Bans Garbage Incineration

July 1, 1998 Governor Tom Carper signed a bill banning garbage incineration in Delaware's "Coastal Zone". A massive outpouring of citizen opposition against the proposed Pigeon Point incinerator site between New Castle and Wilmington did the job.

Meanwhile, a new Environmental Protection Agency study suggests that bar-kyard bum barrels may be a huge source of dioxin and furans in the environment Burning PVC plastic, which is.50 percent chlorine, without emission control is guaranteed to be a problem.

Backyard burning will certainly be eventually banned nationally. One to eleven bum barrels of household waste were found to emit as much dioxin and furans as a modem 200 ton per day trash incinerator.

  • Waste Not, "Ban the burn barrels ", 42 7 (June 1998)
  • "Delaware garbage incineration ban ",431 (July 1998)

Sacred Places of Manteo, North Carolina

The Alliance for Sustainable Communities of Annapolis, Maryland has available a new 18 minute video by Randy Hester entitled, "Community Planning in Manteo, North Carolina7'. It's another approach to community based planning and local empowerment that has produced such good results in Chattanooga, Seattle, Dayton, Cleveland and elsewhere.

Manteo was one of those small towns you see across the nation, desperate for any type of economic development they could get. With 20 percent unemployment, they were willing to sell their souls to for anything. Complicating things was that the white mayor and a principal black council member were not getting along at all.

The concept was to persuade a wide range of citizens to participate in describing a "sacred structure" of their town - to map them. For example, an old gravel parking lot was considered sacred because that is where the community held its festivals twice a year. The wetlands and town hall were considered sacred spots.

And a town design was developed out of the process, with an economic plan in hannony with this. Every community has some resources such as a river, or trees, or transportation as Randy Hester notes. It's a process which he calls "finding fishheads". If there were no resources, the town would not have developed just at that place. Manteo had a wooden boat building industry.

The local people wanted to maintain the small town character and the rural character as part of their "Sacred Structure", and they wanted boundaries and front porches.


Turning Away The Rouse Company

Out of this process came a plan calling for the enlargement of the wooden boat center, the building of a replica colonial boat, Elizabeth 11 which brings in 1,000 people a day, plans for other facilities, a com- munity built boardwalk, low income housing all with sitting porches, and public rocking chairs and bikes.

A proposal by the Rouse Company for a five story commercial waterfront was turned down because it was out of scale and infringed with the Sacred Areas. Instead, the community laid out its own waterfront development resulting in reduced unemployment.

  • Alliance for Sustainable Communities, 111 Hickory Lane, Annapolis, Md. 21401 (contribution)


Back to Top


Warmest Month in 600 Years – Global Warming Here


Weather Bureau Confirms Warming

Thomas Karl of the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) pointed out that July was the warmest month in 600 years, and 1997 the hottest year worldwide since reliable record-keeping was begun over a century ago.

NOAA's National Climatic Data Center released a report in March plotting temperatures over the century, demonstrating a strong upward trend line of combined land-air surface and sea surface temperatures. The authors concluded:

". . . NCDC would like to emphasize that the relative ranking of the year's temperature (in this case the warmest) is not as important as the fact that the warming trend is continuing. The trend is probably real, as there are several other independent indicators that are consistent with the observed trends (sea level rise, glacier retreat) . . ."

Two other NOAA reports show that 20th Century US rainfall and other precipitation is at record levels - averaging 5 to 10 percent higher across the United States than 96 years earlier. There was much increased incidence of heavy storm events. (See chart.) Hot weather evaporates more moisture, and so higher overall rainfall is consistent with global warming.

  • Quayle, Robert, G. et at, "The NCDC global temperature index", Earth System Monitor, National Climatic Data Center, (March 1998)

Precipitation Increases an Average of 5 to 10 Percent Across the United States in the Past 96 Years, With Much Increased Very Heavy Storm Events. (It's another sign of global warming, because warm air will evaporate and carry more moisture.)

Greatest Increase in Heavy storms 20th Century U.S. Precipitation Trends
The map here shows U.S. precipitation trends from 1900 to 1996 (in percent of normal annual precipitation), within state climatic divisions. The diameter of the circle centered within each climatic division reflects the magnitude of the trend.
Larger circles have the greater trends. Solid circles reflect increasing precipitation; open circles reflect decreasing precipitation.
Precipitation AmountThe accompanying histogram shows precipitation trends (in percent per century) for various categories of precipitation amounts (in percentiles) over the contiguous United States,from 1910 to 1996.

Sources: Map
Thomas Karl/NOAA National Climatic Data Center. See Karl, T.R. and R.W. Knight, 1996: "Indices of ciimate change for the United States", Bull. Amer. Meteor. Soc., 77, 279-292.
Histogram
Thomas Karl/NOAA Natioal Climatic Data Center. See Karl, T.R. and R.W. Knight, 1998: "Secular trends of precipitation amount, frequency, and intensity in the USA", Bull. Arner. Meteor. Soc., in press, February 1998.


Low Energy Buildings and Energy-10

Several new software computer programs are now available to assist architects in design of buildings that consume much less energy without loss of comfort.

They were presented at the Solar Energy Conference in Albuquerque in June. One of the most exciting is Energy-10. Dr. J. Douglas Balcomb described their use of Energy-10 software to design an energy efficient building at Sonoma State University in California.

When an architect types in local weather conditions and building type and orientation, the computer in less than 15 minutes (you can get a cup of coffee) can produce a list of efficiency improvements and equipment sizes, ranked by importance, that will reduce building energy use by 60 to 80 percent under code while improving liveability and reducing building costs. For example, daylighting can be very effective.

  • J. Douglas Balcomb, National Renewabk Energy Laboratory, Golden, Colorado

Using Less Energy Economically Smart

Numerous economic studies confirm that reduction of energy use - even where this is achieved with carbon or fuel taxation - will increase jobs and economic growth. One of the latest of such studies was published by the Tellus Institute for the State of New York.

A $50 per ton carbon tax, three quarter of which is recycled to reduce other taxes and one quarter of which used to invest in energy efficiency programs, increased employment by.74% over trendline by the year 2012, and economic output by .35%.

  • Bernow, Stephen et al, Ecolooical Tax Reform: Carbon Taxes With Tax Reductions in New York, Tellus Inst., Boston, Mass. (June 1997)



Japan Proposed Ban of TBT

Tributyl Tin (TBT), the ship and boat paint used to prevent the growth of barnacles, has proven so toxic to aquatic life that its use was banned by the United States in 1989 for smaller craft under 25 meters. Most European nations also have similar restrictions. We have urged EPA to do more about the organic tins.

TBT alters the sex of shellfish and has been linked to the death of California's sea otters. The agricultural fungicide tiiphenytin has been suggested as one cause for the widespread death of amphibians such as frogs around the world. The use of organotins as a stabilizer for PVC water pipes has also led to concern about the effects of organic tin on the health of people.

The finding of tributyl tin in the deep shipping lanes led to a proposal of Japan at the United Nations's International Maritime Organization for a total ban for TBT for all ships and marine structures. The proposal could be ready for formal adoption by IMO by early 1999 and then forwarded for ratification to the 155 IMO nation members.

There are good safer alternatives on the market with Japan in the lead. Japan manufactures a large portion of the world's ships and they also eat a lot of fish.

  • Environ. Sci. & Technot., "Global ban on organotin ship paints proposed by UN maritime group ", (June 1, 1998) and 32 (1998) 1169



Manganese in Gasoline (MMT)

Despite the fact that the major automobile companies Ford, Chrysler, General Motops and Toyota find that manganese additive to gasoline (MMT) damages the engine and emission control systems of motor vehicles, the Environmental Protection Agency has still refused to reopen the issue and ban the metal additive here. Manganese has been linked to Parkinson's disease, motor neuron disease, violent behavior in humans, and learning disabilities in children.

Meanwhile, the Ethyl Corporation has sued the Canadian government for $251 million under the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) for restricting the use of MMT in gasoline to protect the heath of children and the elderly.

Ethyl claims that Canada's actions "unreasonably interfere with the effective enjoyment of Ethyl Canada's property" and that the mere act of debating the bills to restrict MMT by the Canadian Parliament damages the reputation of the company. So much for free speech.

A similar treaty entitled the Multilateral Agreement on Investment, proposes to adopt the exact same free speach and Constitutional stifling provisions throughout OECD, which includes the United States. A large citizen coalition has formed to stop it.




Drinking Water Aluminum and Alzheimer's Link Moves Forward

A French study concludes that the threshold of aluminum in drinldng water below which no relation- ship was seen to elderly cognitive impairment, "was very low (3.5 ug/liter) and did not support the hypothesis of a deleterious effect for only high levels of aluminum".

Chronic Elevation of Blood Levels: We have produced a new chartbook summarizing many studies proving that Alzheimer's patients suffer from a chronic elevation of blood aluminum.2

Aluminum Removal Therapies: Dr. John Savory of the University of Virginia finds that he can reverse the brain tangles in rabbits with chelation (removal) of aluminum. A successful 1991 University of Toronto human clinical trial for Alzheimer's used the iron chelator desferrioxarnine to remove the aluminum from the brain. Dr. Savory has developed a way to make this program easier for elderly couples.

An inexpensive chelator that patients can use without doctor's help is silicic acid. Beer contains about 3 parts per million which is quite effective. An exciting finding by South African researchers is that melatonin, the sleep inducing drug, may also be a brain based aluminum chelator. Older people experience a sharp fall in melatonin levels as they age. And zinc supplements have shown to compete with aluminum as a therapy.

Where You Could Help: The next step towards a US primary drinking water standard for aluminum takes place August 6, 1999 when the Environmental Protection Agency decides whether there is enough health data on aluminum to regulate it. If you could contact your congressional representative, we have lots of information.

  • Jacqmin-Gadda,,Helen et al, "Silica and aluminum in drinking water and cognitive impairment in the elderly", Epidemiology 7 (1996) 281-285
  • Limson, J. et al, "The interaction of melatonin and its precursors with almninum.... " J. Pineal Research 24 (1998) 15-21
  • Savory, John, et al, "Reversal by desferrioxmine of tau protein aggregates ..." NeuroToxicology 1912 (1998) 209-214

(2) Chartbook: 49 pages, $5 to Dept. Planet Earth




We Petition North American CEC on Great Lakes Pollution by Incinerators

On May 27,1998, we submitted a petition to the North American Commission for Environmental Cooperation (CEC) based in Montreal which manages the environmental side agreements of NAFTA, the free trade agreement between the United States, Canada, and Mexico.

We asked them to investigate the failure of the United States to implement the provisions of the US Clean Air Act and the Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement with regard to municipal and medical waste incinerators.

In particular, the Agreement requires that both nations aim at "virtual elimination of persistent toxic substances" like dioxins and mercury. Neither nation has such a program. Our petition is now on their Website. Their E mail address is: csbert@ccemtl.org

News Brief:

The feisty and persistent environmentalist and publisher Marjory Stoneman Douglas died in May at the age of 108. She spent her life trying to save the Everglades and succeeding.




EPA Claims US Produces Only l% of Dioxin

Since then, the Environmental Protection Agency has revised its national dioxin figures and claims "drastic" improvement. The Agency now claims that the United States is responsible for less than 1 percent of all airborne dioxin in the world, even though we bum 23 percent of all fuel and use a large portion of all chlorine worldwide. It seems like EPA is "virt"ly eliminating" dioxin with a stroke of the pen.




US Girls Found to Develop Puberty at Extremely Young Age of Three

The profound effect of endocrine disrupting man-made chemicals in the environment can be seen from the accelerated development of young girls. A North Carolina office practice study found that 1 percent of young white girls and 3 percent of young black girls were developing breasts and pubic hair by the age of 3 years. (Future cancer risks may be likely.)

Peter Montague, writing in the Ecologist, called this a modern obscenity, pointing out that current medical texts find that historically only one percent of young girls show signs of puberty before the age of eight. Here we are talking about the age of three.

In a related analysis, Dr. Frederick vom Saal of the University of Ntssouri has been studying the effects of exposure to very low doses of chemicals like DDT, (1 ppb) during pregnancy. In the laboratory animals, levels like this increase the size of the prostate of the male offspring, reduce testes size, and cause aggressive behavior. (Today two thirds of US men have enlarged prostates by the age of 65 - an expensive proposition.)

The huge number of US children now taking the drug Ritilin for aggressive behavior could well be related to fetal insult by endrocrine disrupting chemicals. Recent findings suggest that Ritilin may also predispose these hyperactive children to drug abuse in the future.

  • Herman-Giddens, Marcia, E. et al, "Secondary sexual characteristics and menses in young girls... " Pediatrics, 9914 (April 1997)
  • Montague, Peter, "The Ecologist" 2813 (May/June 1998)
  • Motluk, Alison, "Calm before the storm", New Scientist (April 18, 1998
  • )
  • vom Saal, Frederick, "Getting to the truth: what we know and don't know about the hazards of endrocrine disrupting chemicals" Pesticides and You 1713 (Fall 1997)
 

END


Copyright © 2000 - Department of the Planet Earth, Inc.
Last Updated:  December 15, 2000

Forest Rivers Designs WLP Consulting, Inc.WLP Consulting, Inc.